Hotlist
BookTokCreators
Hotlist

Your next great read, already waiting.

AboutPrivacyTerms

© 2026 Hotlist. Made for romance readers.

Cover of I Wish You Were Mine

Is it hot?

I Wish You Were Mine

by Jessica Peterson · Harbour Village #2

2024 · 342 pages · Peterson Paperbacks, LLC

Listen ↗
Forced ProximitySmall TownGrumpy / SunshineAge Gap
3.8Goodreads
4.2Amazon
3.9romance.io

Ratings link to their original sources; spice is sourced from romance.io, Hotlist readers, or clearly marked estimates.

Spice🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️· estimated ⓘ
Buy options

Your Take

Save this to your reading shelf and teach Hotlist what your kind of hot looks like.

Before reading

After reading

Trying to decide?

Compare it before you commit.

Save this book to a Hotlist to weigh ratings, spice, tropes, and reader reactions next to your other contenders.

Search authorBuy options

Your Hotlist lens

Want a personal verdict?

Build your lens once, then Hotlist can judge whether books like this are your kind of hot.

Build your Hotlist lens

What Makes It Hot

💬 Mentioned in 10+ Reddit threads

📚 Book 2 of a completed 3-book series

About this book

When you show up to interview as a live-in nanny for a grumpy, tattooed single dad, you know you're walking into trouble—but you need the paycheck for school, so you take the job anyway. What you don't expect is how quickly you'll fall for his adorable four-year-old daughter, or how the brooding exterior of your boss will slowly crack to reveal something unexpectedly tender underneath. Late-night conversations lead to simmering tension that finally ignites in one unforgettable night of passion, but when you wake up alone, you think that's the end of the story—until two pink lines suggest otherwise. Now you and Tuck have to navigate what comes next, and this grumpy dad is about to discover that the best surprises are sometimes the ones you never saw coming.

AI-generated synopsis

Reading soundtrack

Listen while you read

Spotify
yearningintimatesmolderingtenderelectrifying

Sultry indie-pop and R&B with simmering tension—late-night vulnerability meets slow-burn passion. Think intimate acoustic moments that crack open into sensual, electric desire. Yearning vocals over bedroom pop and alternative soul. Soft yet undeniably steamy.

Open in Spotify

Alternate vibes

💬 Join the Discussion

Books with Accidental pregnancy trope where one mc is already a ...

r/RomanceBooks

I Wish You Were Mine: A Single Dad/Nanny, Accidental Pregnancy ...

amazon.co.uk

“If you love ___, you'll like ___.” Give your best comparisons! - Reddit

r/RomanceBooks

Age gap nanny romance with surprise pregnancy : r/RomanceBooks

r/RomanceBooks

: I Wish You Were Mine by Jessica Peterson - Instagram

instagram.com

Harbour Village

1I Wish I Knew Then
2I Wish You Were Minecurrent
3I Wish We Had Forever

Get this book

Ready when you are.

Not quite? Search another book →
Read on Kindle →AmazonB&NBookshop
See reviews on Goodreads ↗
Buy